Skip to content 
Top 10 Philadelphia Slip and Fall Myths
Slip and fall cases are full of assumptions that feel true but aren’t, and they span every setting: sidewalks, stores, parking lots, and winter weather alike. Here are 10 of the most common Philadelphia slip and fall myths we hear, spanning every setting from a corner bodega to a snow-covered parking lot, and what the law actually says.
Myth #1: The City Is Responsible for Public Sidewalks
Fact: In Philadelphia, it’s usually the opposite. The private property owner adjacent to a sidewalk, not the city, is generally responsible for keeping that stretch reasonably safe, including cracks, uneven slabs, and tree-root damage. Many people assume a public sidewalk means a public defendant, which isn’t how it typically works here.
Myth #2: A “Wet Floor” Sign Protects a Business From Liability
Fact: A warning sign helps, but it doesn’t automatically eliminate a business’s responsibility. If the hazard itself was unreasonably dangerous, if the sign was poorly placed or hard to see, or if the spill was allowed to sit for an unreasonably long time before being addressed at all, a claim can still exist even with a sign present. Signage reduces risk; it doesn’t erase the underlying duty to maintain a safe property.
Myth #3: Only the Store Is Responsible for a Fall in Its Parking Lot
Fact: Not necessarily. Retail parking lots are often owned or maintained by a separate property management or landlord entity rather than the store operating inside the building. That can mean more than one potentially responsible party, the retailer, the property owner, and sometimes a third-party maintenance or snow-removal contractor, depending on who controlled the specific area where the fall happened.
Myth #4: A Small Local Business Can’t Afford to Pay a Claim, So It’s Not Worth Pursuing
Fact: Most businesses, including small local stores and bodegas, carry commercial liability insurance specifically to cover situations like this. A claim is typically paid through that insurance policy, not out of the business owner’s own pocket, which means the size of the business doesn’t necessarily reflect what’s available to compensate an injury.
Myth #5: You Have to Fall Inside the Store for It to Count
Fact: A property owner’s or business’s duty of care generally extends to the entire premises a visitor is reasonably expected to use, including entryways, exterior walkways, and parking areas, not just the interior floor space. A fall on an icy entrance ramp or a cracked walkway leading to the door is treated the same as a fall on the sales floor.
Myth #6: If I Don’t Know Exactly Why I Fell, I Don’t Have a Case
Fact: Not knowing the precise cause in the moment doesn’t end a potential claim. An investigation, including photos taken shortly after, witness accounts, incident reports, and sometimes surveillance footage, can often establish what caused a fall even if it wasn’t immediately obvious to the person who fell.
Myth #7: Claims Against the City or a Government Property Work the Same as Claims Against a Private Owner
Fact: They don’t. Claims involving city-owned property, like a municipal building or certain public walkways, require formal written notice within six months of the injury, far shorter than the standard two-year deadline for a typical claim against a private property owner. Missing that notice window can end an otherwise valid claim.
Myth #8: Property Owners Have 24 Hours to Shovel Snow in Philadelphia
Fact: The real window is much shorter. Under Philadelphia Code § 10-720, property owners, agents, and tenants must clear a path of at least 36 inches on sidewalks abutting their property within just six hours after snow stops falling, not 24. This gap between assumption and actual law often matters in a winter fall case.
Myth #9: If I Slip on Ice, the Property Owner Is Automatically Liable
Fact: Pennsylvania’s “hills and ridges” doctrine, established in Rinaldi v. Levine, 176 A.2d 623 (Pa. 1962), generally protects property owners from liability for the kind of generally slippery conditions that come with winter weather. To succeed on a natural-accumulation ice claim, an injured person typically has to show that snow or ice accumulated into ridges or elevations substantial enough to unreasonably obstruct travel, that the owner had notice of that specific condition, and that the dangerous accumulation, not just general slipperiness, caused the fall. Two important exceptions apply, though: a localized, isolated ice patch doesn’t require this showing, and neither does an icy condition caused by the owner’s own negligence, such as a leaking gutter.
Myth #10: A Pre-Existing Condition Means I Can’t Pursue a Claim
Many people assume that having a prior back problem, a previous injury, or another pre-existing condition means they can’t pursue a slip and fall claim, or that any settlement would be worthless. In practice, Pennsylvania law generally allows recovery for the aggravation of a pre-existing condition, meaning a claim isn’t automatically disqualified just because an injury made something worse rather than starting from nothing.
Why These Myths Matter
Believing one of these myths at the wrong moment, walking away without reporting a fall because you assume the sign protects the store, or letting a city sidewalk claim’s notice deadline pass because you assumed you had two years like any other case, can genuinely cost someone a valid claim. Understanding which of these apply to your specific situation is exactly the kind of thing worth a quick conversation with an attorney before deciding there’s nothing to pursue.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is responsible for a public sidewalk fall in Philadelphia?
Generally the private property owner adjacent to the sidewalk, not the City of Philadelphia itself.
Does a wet floor sign eliminate a store’s liability?
No. A sign can reduce risk, but it doesn’t automatically eliminate the underlying duty to address a hazard reasonably.
Can more than one party be responsible for a parking lot fall?
Yes. A retailer, a separate property management company, and a maintenance contractor can all potentially share responsibility depending on who controlled the area.
How long do I have to file a claim against the City of Philadelphia?
Claims against a government unit require written notice within six months of the injury, far shorter than the standard two-year deadline for private claims.
How long do Philadelphia property owners have to shovel snow?
Six hours after snow stops falling, under Philadelphia Code § 10-720.
Does Pennsylvania’s hills and ridges doctrine mean I can never win an ice-related fall claim?
No. It applies mainly to general, storm-related slipperiness. Localized ice patches and owner-caused unnatural accumulation are treated differently and don’t require the same showing.
Can I still pursue a claim if I already had a back or joint problem before the fall?
Generally, yes. Pennsylvania law typically allows recovery for the aggravation of a pre-existing condition, not just entirely new injuries.
About J. Fine Law Firm, P.C.
J. Fine Law Firm, P.C. represents injured people across Philadelphia in slip and fall claims spanning every type of fall we see, from sidewalks and parking lots to store floors and winter hazards. Founding attorney Jason Fine leads the firm’s premises liability practice, working alongside attorney Joe LaRosa to cut through common misconceptions and evaluate what a specific fall actually involves under Pennsylvania law.
If You’ve Fallen and Aren’t Sure Whether You Have a Case
A lot of people talk themselves out of a valid claim based on an assumption that turns out to be wrong. If you or a loved one has fallen on a sidewalk, in a parking lot, inside a store, or on ice or snow anywhere in Philadelphia, J. Fine Law Firm, P.C. can help sort out which of these situations actually applies to you. Call 1-888-913-3899 or request a free consultation to talk through what happened. There’s no cost to have that conversation.